Aristotle Armstrong

Aristotle Armstrong
The thrawn, alternative voice of Scottish Rugby

Thursday, 14 February 2019

We Learn A Little Bit More About Super-6

IT WASN'T quite a case of: “Weel, ye ken noo,” but, we do know a smidgen more about Super-6 following a typical piece of SRU sleight of hand yesterday. There is a news item up on the official SRU website, about Super-6. There is an in-depth piece about the new competition, including the proposed season's outline, but, I'm buggered if I can find it.


I know it exists, because a friendly club official sent me a copy, however, I have as yet been unable to find more than the on line precis. But, hey, that's the SRU way. Why make things easy for people who are trying to do them a favour by mentioning this latest project.

OK, the mainstream media is not at all interested in any rugby below Edinburgh and Glasgow, but, it might have crossed the mind of somebody in the SRU's media department – there are guys out there interested in Super-6 and Agenda-3, let's keep them up to speed.

The SRU media department head

Methinks the Tennent's Premiership is not the only part of Scottish Rugby that is “not fit for purpose,” maybe somebody should take MH, the SRU's version of Buddy the Elf outside and use him for rucking practise.

Any way – back to Maverick, as they said. The S6 Update Document runs to ten pages; a lot of it we already knew, so I will concentrate here on the bits we didn't know, and, of course, the bits which are likely to continue the fighting over this new development in the game.

I appreciate, the Rugby World Cup is a bit of an impediment to 2019-20 being a “normal” season, but that is unavoidable. S6 is due to kick-off on the weekend of 26 October and 2 November, with a couple of friendlies – these are the dates for the World Cup semi-finals and final.

The first of what will be ten, regular-season fixtures kicks off on the weekend of November 9, and there will be six straight weeks of domestic games, before the holiday season shut-down, following the games on the weekend of 14 December. In early 2020, there will be games on 18 and 25 January and 1 February, before the final regular season game on 22 February.

The domestic part of S6 closes with the play-off semi-finals on 7 March, with the final on 28 March. There will be no S6 games on 6 Nations weekends.

At the moment, we don't know if the S6 games will be played on Friday nights, Saturday afternoons, or even Sundays – that will be up to the clubs involved, but the suggestion is, some might wish to keep Saturday afternoons free for the six franchises Club sides.

I doubt very much that we will see S6 games on a Friday night when Edinburgh and Glasgow are playing and the timing of games is one aspect of S6 still being worked out. Also still up in the air is when the cross-border games against the Welsh Premiership clubs will be played.

There is certainly a window at the start of the season, however, the fact that the first two weeks listed in the prototype calendar – 26 October and 2 November – have been set aside for friendlies, makes me think the cross-border games will be played in April and May; we must wait to find out, however.

The meat on the bone of the document comes in page 6, with the mention of dual-registration, whereby players may be registered with another club, in addition to the S6 club. This is a potential mine field, and is likely to be the most-contentious area of the whole project.

That same page also announced there will be a new addition to the SRU's existing Player Reward Scheme, whereby a player who signs a contract with an S6 club earns a wee bonus for the club or clubs or school which developed him. This payment is £400 per player. His career over the previous five years is looked at with the club or clubs he played for in that time being rewarded at £80 per season.

So, for example (and again I am using clubs from my own Ayrshire) suppose Ayr signed a player who had spent three seasons with Marr, having moved there from Cumnock, then Marr would receive £240 (3 x £80) and Cumnock £160 (2 x £80) under the scheme. I appreciate, some clubs might not feel this is sufficient compensation, but, it is a start.

Each franchise will be managed by a Board, with at least five members: three officials from the core club, the Head Coach and an SRU representative, who we are assured will act in an advisory and consultative capacity.

The document does not answer all the outstanding questions. For instance, towards the end there is an indication that Super-6 may not be the final outcome. It is already well-known that the SRU has task forces in place, looking at how best to expand S6 to S8 or perhaps S10, with scope for further expansion in Glasgow, the Borders and Caledonia.

The document appears to confirm, the SRU is definitely looking to expand the number of franchises, but, again, when this will happen is all up in the air. A lot of talking and exploring of options will still have to be undertaken.

In a recent blog, I suggested the SRU should be looking to get more fixtures for the Club XV, and this expansion in games is mentioned towards the end of the update document. However, talks are ongoing as to whether or not the Club XV will contain S6 players, and we may not know for some time about this. However, S6 is definitely part of the SRU's High Performance structure, and “ownership” of the Club XV is being transferred to Sheila Begbie's Rugby Development Department.

This leads me to think, perhaps an expanded programme of Club XV games, just might be another level of talent identification and sorting-out, with the best young Championship/Premiership players, perhaps through performances for the Club XV, being assessed as possible S6 players.

Super-6 Proect Manager Zoe Paige

And finally, we now have a name as to who will be the off-field administrator for S6. Zoe Paige, currently one of the SRU's marketing managers, has been handed the role of Project Manager; what happens off the field is her domain, while, as we already know, Sean Lineen will be in-charge of things as regards the players.

Well, we are a wee bit further down the road to seeing Super-6 up and running.

The full Update Document can be read at:



5 comments:

  1. Other interesting snippets

    * possibility that S6 franchise won’t be able to field a 2nds or 3rds due to player numbers
    * still pushing for 4G pitches though still no indication of where the cash will come from.
    * realisation that S6 sides will need floodlights. I assume to playing standard
    * there are two items that will drain the pots available to ordinary clubs

    And can the SRU stop this nonsense about “clubs”. The S6 sides are all limited companies managed by a board of directors. Sensibly so given the risks involved.

    They are not and never have been clubs.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The SRU have announced the players will be employed by the Club, so not the ltd liability companies that surely each are setting up to run the franchise.

    Are these professional players, employed by amateur Clubs, covered by the Unions player insurance policy?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Looks like there's an SRU oxymoron in there, trying to get out!

      Delete
    2. And of course a “club” or unicorporated association has no legal personality so cannot legally take on a contract. If a club wishes to take on a contract it’s usually the officials personally that are signing on the bottom line.

      To be fair to the SRU, Scottish football does the same thing. Very few clubs still playing in the pro leagues.

      Delete
  3. So has Stevie Gemell now adopted LSJ's leadership style of operating in the shadows? I thought this was his gig?

    ReplyDelete