Aristotle Armstrong

Aristotle Armstrong
The thrawn, alternative voice of Scottish Rugby

Saturday, 14 November 2020

Further Delay To The Accounts Is Sheer Madness


EURIPIDES had a point, if he did indeed come up with: “Those whom the Gods would destroy – they first make mad.”


If the old Athenian dramatist was around today, he might well be chronicling the tragedies of the Scottish Rugby Union's Junta. The latest of these came at Friday tea time, when, whichever of the elves was charged with locking-up at BT Murrayfield, while the big important people were off in Florence, gazing at Michelangelo's David and the other touristy must-sees, put out that shameful club communication which told us – the accounts have been delayed again – until DECEMBER.


American humorist Will Rogers often gets the credit for another aphorism I would today direct towards The Junta: “When you're in a hole, stop digging.”


TCD and his loyal side-kick Howzat have been in a hole, ever since they apparently conspired to be rid of “a turbulent priest” named Keith Russell. However, emboldened by a supine Council, they have continued to dig. Now, we have the current situation, whereby the accounts are so late in being revealed, the conspiracy theorists are having a ball.


According to the SRU bye laws, the books should have been opened within four months of the end of May. OK, given the double whammy of prolonged illness on the part of Finance Director Andrew Healy, who I wish a speedy recovery, as I understand he is again off work with illness, plus the Covid-19 pandemic, the SRU have been granted a degree of licence in when they open the books to the membership. But, with the further delay, which they sneaked out on Friday, I can only assume, The Junta is having a further larf at the clubs' expense.


The delay, since May, has been unacceptable. This latest hold up is Totally defenceless. Surely there has to be a way by which we can get them available.


Instead – we got the following weasel words, in a statement sent out to clubs on Friday evening:

 

“The current pandemic has created circumstances where additional work needs to be done before the accounts are approved, providing an additional level of assurance for the organisation and stakeholders that the impact of the pandemic on the organisation has been fully examined and can be explained to members. That work is taking longer than anticipated.


Ensuring that members are informed about the effect of the pandemic on the organisation and our sport more generally, and in particular, have sufficient time to consider the financial statements and ask questions about them, is a priority for the Council and Board.



It is therefore proposed that a financial presentation will be given to members at Stage 2 of the AGM, with more detailed financial information following shortly thereafter.



Following discussion, and with the support of the Scottish Rugby Council, Stage 2 of the resumed AGM on 26 November will therefore focus on club and domestic rugby issues, including the motions submitted by clubs, presentation of the preliminary results for the 19/20 financial year, and commentary on the organisation’s response to the pandemic and its impact on the current 20/21 year.



The Annual General Meeting will then be adjourned, to enable the Special General Meeting to be held in respect of Biggar RFC’s motion.



The formal laying of financial statements will take place later in December, allowing stakeholders adequate time in advance to study the accounts and submit questions ahead of that resumed meeting.”



Perhaps we had too-great expectations of President Ian Barr and the new brooms on the Council, but, today, they really need to get together and force TCD and the minions to make them available. Because, that statement was pure pish.


I don't expect, even though Covid will have only minimal impact on the delayed figures, the accounts to make easy reading. Difficult questions will, I believe, need to be answered, but, I am also certain the 2019-20 accounts will look wonderful, compared to what we can expect when the 2020-21 figures come out. So, they may as well reveal the bad news, if only to prepare us for the even-worse news in a year or so's time.


They had the perfect opportunity on Friday, with Scotland nursing a national headache after the drama of Thursday night in Belgrade. Between that and the diversion of this afternoon's match in Florence, yesterday was the perfect day on which to bury bad news, but, even when it was to their advantage, the stumblebums on The Junta couldn't take it.


For Fuck Sake, even Ollie McBurnie took his chance when he scored with his penalty. Will David Marshall be the SRU's next big-name signing? Methinks the Junta is going to need someone to save their jerseys when this accounts shite does finally hit the fan.


To return to old Euripides. Given the justifiable ill will towards them from a goodly percentage of the membership; given the way we have had calamities following disasters following mistakes since Russellgate 1, you would think The Junta might have been trying a wee bit harder to get things right.


But, no, it seems not, like Ole Blue Eyes himself, TCD just seems to keep doing things His Way, and the faithful elves follow him.


Aye, Euripides did indeed have a point; since, not even appearing to try to placate an angry membership is a sure sign of madness.


Finally, during Armistice Week, SRU Past President Ed Crozier posted on Facebook, a wee clip from the finale of that wonderful play The Big Picnic, which he helped produce. It was the full cast, singing Horatius Bonar's and Ira D Sankey's marvellous hymn Only Remembered. I defy any Scot not to shed a tear when he or she watches that.


I fear, when TCD, Howzat and some others in The Junta are finally shown the Murrayfield door, they will only be remembered for the wrongs they did to Scottish Rugby.














3 comments:

  1. Last years figures won't be the issue, they'll include World Cup income, they'll include CVC income, that's why your insider close to the corridors of power was more than happy to tip you off about better than expected accounts.

    However, along comes the auditors, who in normal years will say yeh they look fine and are willing to put their name to the auditors report and sign off on the going concern statement. However, these are far from normal times.

    Slightly stretching the truth (remember the debt free one), when there is a risk the corporate entity may not be sustainable means the auditors good name may be called into question. Instead of questioning how ambitious you are on the upside, they're now looking at the downside.

    Their £34 raffle tickets are being sold on the assumption that there will (or would have been) crowds at autumn tests, 6 nations & Lions matches at Murrayfield, but what happens if there is no crowd.

    What happens if CVC have a get out clause, or penalty clauses.

    These are the sorts of questions that no doubt the auditor has posed, and which I'm guessing the cheery marketing chappies from EH12 have failed to provide suitable answers to.

    With yesterdays strange statement about needing to provide "an additional level of assurance for the organisation and stakeholders", the question stakeholders should be asking is:

    "What remains if it's judged the corporate entity is not unsustainable?"

    As you have suggested previously, I could pose this question to my Council member, but I'm guessing I'll just get another cut & paste response (no doubt drafted from an employee).

    #spleenventing

    ReplyDelete
  2. Got to love the Scottish Rugby Exec. How to make a drama into a crisis.

    If the warning lights weren’t already flashing, we as clubs are benign given fair warning that things are not good at HQ.

    I fully expect deflection and no answers at AGM part 2

    ReplyDelete
  3. The more the Junta procrastinate the more suspicious the Hoi Polloi will get

    ReplyDelete