Aristotle Armstrong

Aristotle Armstrong
The thrawn, alternative voice of Scottish Rugby

Thursday, 7 March 2019

A Welcome Bit Of Clarity On The World League Proposals

FAIR PLAY to World Rugby, after all the leaks and speculationabout the proposed World League, they wasted little time in getting out an explanation of their thinking, in advance of next week's Dublin Summit.

The press release appears to contradict some of the sensationalised pieces which have been written in the past week – no mention, for instance of the Pacific Island nations being side-lined in favour of arguably more commercially-attractive rivals, Japan and the USA. Indeed, in an accompanying video, World Rugby makes it clear, if the World League was starting immediately, Fiji would be in. Full details of the World Rugby press release can be read at:


The new league's schedule is complicated and is best looked-at over a four year World Cup cycle. The full schedule operates in the first post World Cup season, i.e. 2019-20; there is a truncated season, without promotion and relegation, in the second season, 2020-21 – to allow for a Lions Tour; another full season in 2021-22 and no World League in 2022-23, which is a World Cup season.

The 6 Nations and the Rugby Championship will continue to operate as now, except two nations will be added to the Championship – at the moment these would be Fiji and Japan, the two highest-ranked southern hemisphere nations.

The new northern hemisphere second division would, if operating now comprise: Georgia, Russia, Spain, Romania, Belgium and Netherlands. In the southern hemisphere, Division Two would comprise: Tonga, USA, Uruguay, Samoa, Canada and Namibia.

The proposed calendar guarantees each nation 11 internationals per calendar year, for the northern hemisphere sides like Scoland, this would mean the normal five during the 6 Nations, two, maybe three games during the summer July international window and three or four during the Autumn internaitonal window, these would be against the six First Division nations in the southern hemisphere.

At the end of these 11 internationals the two leading sides in the two conferences would play-off in cross-conference semi-finals, with the two semi-final winners playing off for the overall World League Champonship. In the video explaining this, this the northern hemisphere semi-finalists are England and Scotland. England beats Australia, and Scotland loses to New Zealand, leaving us with an England v New Zealand Grand Final.

There will also be promotion and relegation, with the bottom team in Division One, playing-off against the Division Two winners to decide which naion goes into the top league in the next season; although there will be no play-off in a Lions year. Below Division Two, there will be a third division, run in four-nation groups. This means emerging nations such as Germany or Brazil would have the chance to advance into the top tier.

The whole set-up is rather akin to the new European Nations League in football, except on a world-wide scale. Of course, there is a lot of horse-trading and talking to be done, but, I for one, am excite by the possibilities.


AT LEAST, there is a degree of clarity in the World Rugby statement. The other big row of the moment, around the Welsh Regions, is still at the stage of being, in Glesca patois - “A stair-heid rammy.”

Wales Online were on their high horse this morning, pointing-out that since “Terrible Tuesday,” when the news of the intended Ospreys/Scarlets merger broke, there had been statements from everyone except the four regional mascots and the Welsh Rugby Union.

I hear from one of my spies in the Valleys, a WRU committee man was even seen out this week without his distinctive blazer, an indication of how far down the Taffia are keeping their heads.

We do things differently in Scotland though – up here TCD, Dirty Dom and and the Gang simply issue directives, and to Hell with anyone who disagrees. This Welsh story will run and run.



AT LUNCH TIME today, Gregor Townsend announced our team to face Wales, at BT Murrayfield on Saturday, a team which shows four changes from that which lost to France last time out.

The return to the colours of Finn Russell and Wilem Nel were hardly surprises, but, the demotion of skipper Greig Laidlaw to the bench, with Ali Price starting, was somewhat unexpected, while, Darcy Graham will make his first 6 Nations start, for the injured Sean Maitland.

The squad, as ever in 1-23 order is:

Allan Dell, Stuart McInally [Captain], Wilem Nel, Grant Gilchrist Jonny Gray, Magnus Bradbury, Jamie Ritchie, Josh Strauss; Ali Price, Finn Russell; Darcy Graham, Pete Horne, Nick Grigg, Tommy Seymour; Blair Kinghorn. Susbtitutes: Gordon Reid, Fraser Brown, Simon Berghan, Ben Toolis, Hamish Watson, Greig Laidlaw, Adam Hastings, Byron McGuigan.

Jonny Gray and Tommy Seymour are set to win their 50th caps in the game.

The Doddie Weir Cup, which Wales hold after the inaugural match, back in the Autumn, is up for grabs on Saturday.



THIS INTERNATIONAL weekend, as always, kicks-off with the Under-20 international, at Meggetland, and the Women's match, at Scotstoun, with both Scottish squads still seeking their first wins of this year's tournament.

Carl Hogg, the Under-20 Coach, has made three changes to his squad for the game, which (again in 1-23 order) is:

Murphy Walker, Ewan Ashman, Euan McLaren, Ewan Johnson, Cameron Henderson, Charlie Jupp, Connor Boyle [Captain], Kwagga van Niekerk; Roan Frostwick, Ross Thompson, Jack Blain, Robbie McCallum, Cameron Anderson, Rory McMichael; Matt Davidson. Replacements : Angus Fraser, Andrew Nimmo, Will Hurd, Ross Bundy, Jack Mann, Murray Scott, Nathan Chamberlain, Ollie Smith.


SHADE MUNRO, the Women's Coach has also rang the changes for his side's game against the Welsh, at Scotstoun, tomorrow night. His squad, again in 1-23 order is:

Megan Kennedy, Lana Skeldon, Mairi Forsyth Emma Wassell, Sarah Bonar, Rachel Malcolm, Rachel McLachlan, Jade Konkel; Mhairi Grieve, Helen Nelson; Annabel Sergeant, Lisa Thomson [Captain], Hannah Smith, Rhona Lloyd; Chloe Rollie. Substitutes: Jodie Rettie, Lisa Cockburn, Katie Dougan, Nicola Howat, Deborah McCormack, Jenny Maxwell, Lisa Martin, Abi Evans.




1 comment: