WATCHING the South v Ayr and The West on my lap top on Saturday was a definite case of deja vu again. I was taken back over 40 years, to the younger, less-cynical me, newly recruited to the rank of a national newspaper football writer, on my first working visit to the old roof-top press box at Ibrox. If we lifted our heads beyond the pitch, we had a panoramic view of thousands and thousands of empty seats.
I checked my records, for the game in question, a 1-0 Rangers win over Motherwell, the official attendance was 18,000. The joke at the time, while Rangers were rebuilding the stadium was, there had been a design fault – the seats were facing the pitch.
That was my thought as I watched the many empty seats in The Greenyards' grandstand. Here we had it, the “winner takes all” climax to the newly-restored Inter-District Championship, being held in what we are always told is “the heartland of Scottish Rugby” and the whole atmosphere was one of apathy.
The match deserved a far-fuller house; much-better selling and certainly, a different date. So, who do we blame? Suggestions to the below the line comments. For me, it was further evidence, if not everyone inside the Murrayfield Junta, at the very least, the Club Rugby Board is not fit for purpose.
The timing was wrong, your average Borders Rugby Fan had to decide: “do I go up to Edinburgh and watch Scotland, or do I give money to Melrose?” That's a toughie. The build-up in the media was virtually non-existent – the game wasn't even listed on the BBC's website. The match deserved far-better than it got.
I am loath to criticise NextGen, the streaming service which covered the game, but, a Google search on Sunday morning brought up lots of schools games, including quite a few from Scotland, but absolutely no mention of this game, or their recent coverage, from the same ground, of Melrose v Ayr. Is Scottish Club Rugby a secret we are not allowed to know about?
As with the Melrose v Ayr game, there were occasional technical glitches – the stream “freezing”, loss of commentary – Club Rugby deserves better, but, apparently, given the previous problems Borders Rugby TV suffered, it's almost as if the high heid yins at Murrayfield don't want to promote the grass roots club game.
Any way, kudos to The South for a typically whole-hearted performance, but, Ayr and the West always had enough power and skill in hand to get the job done.
I WAS fortunate enough to be at that Calcutta Cup match all those years ago when a callow youth named Jim Telfer of Melrose came of age as a Scotland player. That game has been known as “Jim Telfer's Match” ever since. Saturday's destruction of Japan may well in time be known as Liam McConnell's Match, after the youthful Edinburgh flanker stole the show with a hat-trick, on his way to the Man of the Match call.
After his display, it is clear, that greatly-over-hyped English chap, 'The David Beckham of Rugby' one Henry Pillock, is nothing more than “a Poundland Liam McConnell”.
We played some good stuff; several of the fringe players put their hands up for more involvement in the run-on team; we now have perhaps more depth than ever – but, this will not pacify or silence the persistent “Toony Must Go” faction in the Rugby Division of The Tartan Army.
There appeared to be a lot more kids in the crowd on Saturday, which, while I still have my doubts about exposing kids to the roller coaster ride which is lifetime membership of the TA, this was good to see. I particularly enjoyed the TV clip of one wee laddie, perhaps about five or six, singing along to Flower of Scotland. Given that, the Scottish education system is clearly not failing.
I did not realise, until Sunday morning, that the front seat passenger in the Arnold Clark escort car to the Scotland team bus was oor ain Dougie Stanley. I've known Dougie since he was a schoolboy at Ayr Academy. He has done sterling work as Team Manager/Kit Man/General Dogsbody around Millbrae for years, he deserved his moment in the sun – it couldn't happen to a nicer guy.
THE RISE of Wee Hollie Davidson goes on. She had another excellent game in Paris on Saturday night – even the South African keyboard warriors thought she had a good game. However, I would say, she has nae chance of refereeing the big 1v2 final. World Rugby is not yet ready for a Scottish referee, far-less a Scottish WUMMIN referee, officiating such an important game.
Another referee to have a good day on Saturday was England's Christophe Ridley, who drew the short straw of Ireland v South Africa. With The Blessed Rassie banned and missing, the usual keyboard warriors from south of the Limpopo were going to be poised, ready to criticise every decision the Bokke didn't get. If they lost, they would be ready to go after the referee like an angry Zulu impi.
The RFU refereeing pecking order apparently is: 1. Luke Pearce, 2. Karl Dickson, 3. Matthew Carley, 4. Ridley. I reckon right now, he has leap-frogged Carley and Dickson and is closing on the excellent Pearce.

