AS
I strike
these keys to write this blog, there are less than 15 hours remaining
of 2018, a year which I feel the Scottish Rugby community will not be
sad to see the back of. Sure, we have had the odd high – none
higher than thumping England to regain the Calcutta Cup, but, we have
also had some awful lows – Cardiff anyone.
But
for me, Scottish Rugby in 2018 has been like British politics. While
the politicians and the fans of this subject have been besotted by
Brexit, which in truth has become almost like East Enders – a
miserable soap opera, featuring a cast on largely unlikeable
caricatures, going nowhere other than round in circles.
In
Scottish Rugby, we are seeking someone heroic, to rise above the
constant arguing about Super-6, to cut through the uncertainty about
Agenda-3 and to lead us to a promised land where we are relevant in
the world.
The
year 2018 has been dominated by argument, about S6A3, about where the
S6 “amateur” teams would play. Along the way we have had
Russellgate to excite the lieges. I rather think TCD is a wee bit
like Theresa May, kicking the can down the road a bit, playing for
time and hoping something – Gavin MacColl QC and his Governance
Committee maybe, will appear to save him and his beleaguered Board
and Council.
Things
can surely get better and improve in 2019, but, as ever, I am in the
Scottish default position at the gateway to a new year: “An' furrit
tho' Ah cannae see, Ah guess and fear.”
BEFORE
starting
this piece, I had a quick look at what I was writing this time last
year, and, well I never, it was deja vu all over again.
My
last piece of 2017 was all about the Glasgow leg of the 1872 Cup. At
least Mikey Adamson, who had that game, rather than the first leg, as
he had this year, got off a bit more lightly than George Clancy did
at the weekend, but, the refereeing was the main point of discussion.
Twelve
months ago, I said: “Rugby
at the professional level is all but unrefereeable.” Nothing
has happened since then to dissuade me of this view. I do not blame
the match officials, who are making the best of a bad job, but,
again, I wonder what John Jeffrey and his committee on World Rugby
does. I repeat something I have been saying for years – we need a
thorough overhaul of the Laws, and, we certainly need to -
BRING
BACK REAL RUCKING!!!
At
this point one year ago, Glasgow was our top club, today, I am not as
certain of that statement, such is the improvement in Edinburgh since
the players began to buy into Richard Cockerill and his approach. If
you look at who are now Scotland's main players, you have the exiles:
Messrs Laidlaw and Russell, Sean Maitland and the newcomer Sam
Skinner, then you have a phalanx of Edinburgh players – Stuart
McInally, WP Nel, Hamish Watson, Ben Toolis and Grant Gilchrist,
before you get to the first Glasgow player – Stuart Hogg.
In
a year, Jonny Gray has gone from an automatic pick, to arguably being
only our fourth-ranked lock. We are now starting to ask if Ryan
Wilson's nuisance value is still sufficient to place him above the
new back-row bunch – Bradbury, Fagerson minor and Ritchie.
We
are going into a World Cup year, and certainly Gregor Townsend has
some big calls to make.
For
me, THE Scottish players of the year have been Hamish Watson up
front, and Finn Russell behind the scrum, while the breakthrough
player has surely been Darcy Graham.
I
am excited about this year, we have a young international team, but
an improving one. However, we are only a couple of injuries to key
men away from potential disaster.
My
big wish for 2019 is that we can put an end to the bickering in
clubland and sort things out properly. The big battle will be over
where the S6 core clubs play, and I worry about this. Again, we have
to hope Gavin MacColl and his team can come up with something
workable on governance.
The
SRU Board and Council has been concentrating on the performance end
of the game, they now really need to look at clubland, get the guys
at the grass roots onside and end the infighting. But, hey, we're
Scots, infighting is our default position.
I
certainly hope, during January, we can stop kicking the can down the
road and get some things sorted out, because, we are rapidly running
out of time when it comes to sorting-out a few major issues.
Can
I send my sympathies to top referee Lloyd Linton, who endured a
torrid time when given the Italian Derby between Benetton and Zebre
at the weekend.
Firstly,
he was, at one point, pinned at the foot of a ruck by some
over-enthusiastic counter rucking by Benetton; but, he regained his
dignity and control. Then, minutes later he got the ultimate
undignified rugby injury – the sharp end of a booted Gilbert ball
right in the haw maws.
Lloyd
assures me, he counted them, and both are still there, but, this was
a difficult injury to run off. Still, he's a former hooker, the blow
was nothing.
And
finally, can I wish the great WM McMurtrie (Paisley Grammar School,
Galashiels Academy, the Glasgow Herald, Glasgow Warriors, the SRU and
GHA) a better 2019 than 2018 was.
Both
Bill and his good lady have been troubled somewhat with illness over
the past 12 months, but, I understand are now, slowly, on the mend. I
know it embarrasses him when I say this, but, Bill is the best
president the SRU never had, he is one of the few remaining pillars
of wisdom and good sense in the game and we really need him restored
to good health and able to offer his wise counsel throughout the
coming year and hopefully for a guid few years to come.
The
same hopes and good wishes also go to another giant of our game, the
great Allan Hosie, another man who has been spending more time in the
care of the excellent Scottish NHS than we want to see.
So
– have
a great time tonight, a Guid New Year tae ane an' awe – and, see
you across in 2019.










