Aristotle Armstrong

Aristotle Armstrong
The thrawn, alternative voice of Scottish Rugby

Monday, 30 May 2016

No Deal Between the SRU And London Scottish - What Happens Now?



FOR some time now, this blog, and other rugby media outlets, have been calling for the SRU to fund at least a third professional side. The obvious core situation for such a team has, in our opinion, and in the opinion of several other commentators, been London Scottish.
That club has an honoured place in Scottish rugby history, not least from the fact, it has produced more Scotland caps than any other club. It is already functioning as a professional club, and, it seems to us, entirely sensible that the co-operation agreement, which the club and the SRU entered into earlier this season should have been extended and expanded.
Our preferred option would be for Scottish to become a London-based Pro12 club, tapping into the Scottish diaspora in the capital and the greater financial muscle which the Scotia Nostra in the City of London could come up with. Sadly, this aint gonna happen. Scottish have today announced the ending of even their arms-length agreement with the SRU, and, they are making it quite clear, it's Murrayfield's fault.
I dare say, when Murrayfield gets around to explaining their part in the whole minor disaster, theirs will be a different tale, time will tell, but, it is disappointing to see something which promised much, ending so soon and in such rancour.
What happens next? Well, all may not be lost. We keep hearing that the semi-professional Premiership will happen, maybe Murrayfield has decided, their resources are better spent in Scotland, on home-Scots players, playing for Scottish clubs. We must wait and see. Or, maybe they are going to fund the acquisition of some world-class talent for Edinburgh and Glasgow. It might even be, their gin bill has been greater than budgeted for, you never can tell with the blazers.
We can only think, unless they come up with something wonderful from left field, and this is Murrayfield we are talking about, a golden chance might have been lost and the wrong decision has been made – again.

AT LEAST, Dom McKay and his team, by all accounts, made rather a good job of organising Saturday's Guinness Pro12 final, at BT Murrayfield.
Dominic McKay, his team produced a cracking Pro12 final
The day went well, the match attracted a record crowd of nearly 35,000 and Connacht, the underdogs, had their day. Well done Pat Lam, John Muldoon and the men from the West of Ireland. You earned it.

TWO different squads met-up for the first time today. At Murrayfield, the Scotland squad for the Summer Tour to Japan convened, while in London, the Team GB Sevens squad for the Olympic Games met-up for the first time. Good luck to both groups, in particular to the Scots in the Sevens squad.

ITALIAN referee Marius Matrea had the whistle in yesterday's England v Wales match at Twickenham – his first Tier 1 international. He did better there than he has in some Pro12 games, as did his two touch judges – Haud It and Daud It, of George Clancy and John Lacey.

Marius Matrea
Well, that's the top Italian official getting a Tier 1 international, how long must we wait before the top Scottish referee gets a Pro12 game?

Saturday, 28 May 2016

He's Jones the Jock Now

WOW! I never saw that one coming. I do not pay a great deal of attention to South African rugby, and I do not have Sky, therefore, I knew nothing of Huw Jones, and, even if I had heard of him, with that name I would have put his father down as an exiled member of the Taffia.

Huw Jones of Stormers

Well, I ken noo – he's a fully-paid-up member of the Caledonian Diaspora, one of us, and he could well earn his debut Scotland cap during the Summer tour to Japan. Good luck to the boy, at least, his selection shows, Sean Lineen is earning his corn as global scout for eligible Scottish players.

BT MURRAYFIELD goes well and truly green today, with the Guinness Pro12 final seeing the plce taken over by the Murphyia, for the day.
I make no apologies, I am a Connacht man for the duration. They have been a breath of fresh air in this season's Pro12. They have a tenuous SRU connection through Pat Lam's brief spell on the Scotland coaching staff and, they deservedly beat Glasgow in the semi-final. Any way, it would be nice to see, for the second straight year, a new name etched on the Pro12 trophy.

TODAY'S other big game is at Twickenham, where Saracens must overcome Exeter to land an English/European double. This one promises to be an epic encounter, and I find myself torn as to which outcome I would prefer.
My late elder brother played for Saracens, back in the far-off amateur days of the 1960s, when they were arguably the least-fashionable of the senior London clubs. During their brief sojourn in Watford, the guy I sat beside through school, long since embedded with the Scottish Missionary Service in the Sudetenland, was a major sponsor, so, I ought to be wearing my fez and cheering-on Sarries.
Rob Baxter of Exeter
But, a few years back, I covered a pre-season friendly between Exeter and Glasgow, at Millbrae. I had barely heard of that club, and of Rob Baxter, their charismatic Director of Rugby. I left Millbrae as a definite fan. I like the type of rugby they play, I love the togetherness of the club the way they play for each other. This afternoon, as turn on BT Sport to watch, I am, for once, a confirmed fence-sitter.

PETER McCallum, already his own club's Player of the Year, was last night confirmed as Scotland's Club Player of the Year, at the SRU's annual Club Awards Dinner – and quite right too.
Scotland Club XV number eight Peter McCallum receiving his Ayr P-O-Y award from Calum Forrester, has now added the Scottish Club Player of the Year award to his list of honours
Ah Kent his faither, big Chris – who could have gone further than the Scotland Under-21 team, if he could have been arsed. To Chris, rugby was nothing more than a good way to work-up a thirst on a Saturday afternoon. His son, thankfully, takes the game a wee bit more seriously than his Dad did.
Peter has scored tries this season at a rate which, if he had been scoring goals for Ayr United, rather than tries for Ayr RFC, would have earned him a big-money move to a top team. But, more than that, he has proved to be one-third, with Blair Macpherson and Will Bordill, of a very-effective breakaway unit. He also, stood-out in the Scotland Club XV.
He is, however, unlikely to get a call to Glasgow or Edinburgh, since, he is neither tall enough, nor heavy enough to be a professional Number Eight, and not fast enough to be a professional Seven. So, he will go on causing havoc from the base of the Ayr pack, for a wee while yet. However, he was a worthy winner.

Emma Wassell of Murrayfield Wanderers won the equivalent Women's award, while that jammy so-and-so Phil Smith of Heriot's was named Coach of the Year.
Coach of the Year Phil Smith
The complete list of award winners, announced at Murrayfield last night, reads:
BT Club of the Season – Annan
• BT Women’s Club of the Season – Garioch
• Coach of the Season – Phil Smith (Heriot’s)
• Youth Coach of the Season – Gary Coupland (Annan)
• Referee of the Season – Duncan McClement
• Caledonia Best Spirit of Rugby – Mike Dawson (Murrayfield Wanderers)
• BT Volunteer of the Season – Peter Hill (Duns)
• Brigadier Frank Coutts Memorial (BT) Try of the Season – Steven Rutledge (Highland)
• BT Premiership Player of the Season – Peter McCallum (Ayr)
• BT National League Division 1 Player of the Season – Ben Johnston (Marr)
• BT National League Division 2 Player of the Season – Ross Gillies (Cartha Queen’s Park)
• BT National League Division 3 Player of the Season – Tony Herron (GHK)
• BT Caledonia Regional Player of the Season – Andrew Findlater (Highland)
• BT East Regional Player of the Season – Jamie Simpson (Earlston)
• BT West Regional Player of the Season – Corrie Louw (Oban Lorne)
• BT Women’s Premier League Player of the Season – Emma Wassell (Murrayfield Wanderers)
• BT Women’s National League Division 1 Player of the Season – Audrey Barr (Oban Lorne)
• BT Women’s National League Division 2 Player of the Season – Nicola Howat (Howe Harlequins)
• Scottish Rugby Club Development Officers of the Year Awards – Brendan McGroarty (Greenock Wanderers), Colin Sturgeon (Glasgow Life), Graeme Simpson (Falkirk)

Brendan McGroarty - Hawks's skipper's development work has been recognised



Thursday, 26 May 2016

Finn's Fine, But Cotter Must Cogitate On A Replacement

THIS has been a quiet, and in some ways disturbing week, for Scottish Rugby. I believe I speak for many, when I say my greatest concern is the health of Scotland and Glasgow Warriors's stand-off Finn Russell.


 Finn Russell - on the mend and hopefully home soon
It was worrying to learn, Finn was transferred from the local hospital in Galway, to the Beaumont Hospital in Dublin, however, Beaumont is the best facility in the Republic of Ireland for those who have suffered a neurosurgical injury – therefore, he could not be in better hands. Hopefully, he will, as expected, soon be back home in Scotland, and going through the various stages of the SRU's return to action following a head injury protocol. This protocol was, as we all know, written by Dr James Robson and his team, so all being well, Finn should be passed fit to return to action in the new season.
Before then, however, we have the Summer Tour to Japan, and the answer to the question – who fills-in for Finn? Big Vern Cotter has the decision to make, and he appears to have several options.
Ruaridh Jackson - should be our starting 10 in Japan
Or, might Peter Horne get the job?
  1. He could nominate the versatile Peter Horne as back-up to Ruaridh Jackson, who should now go on-tour as our starting stand-off, and for cover bring-in another centre, perhaps taking Mark Bennett out of the preliminary Team GB Olympic Sevens squad.
    Or Duncan Weir?
  2. He could simply call-up Duncan Weir, Russell's deputy for club and country – but, may prefer to allow Dunky to bed-in with new club Edinburgh.
     
    1. He could call-up Greig Tonks, or, more likely Tom Heathcote,  who has garnered some good reviews with his play with Worcester Warriors.
      Greig Laidlaw - another potential fill-in at 10

    3. He might leave the squad as is, since either Horne, skipper Greig Laidlaw, or, as a long shot, Stuart Hogg, could fill-in for Finn at 10.
I suppose we will find out on Monday, when the tour squad meets-up at Murrayfield.

BEFORE then, we have Saturday's Guinness Pro12 Final, at BT Murrayfield, Connacht v Leinster. It will be interesting to see how well Scotland's rugby fans support this game, given Glasgow's failure to qualify. The Irish fans, we know, will travel in numbers, but, it would be nice to think the Scots fans might go along to help off-set the numerical advantage in supporters which the “Dubs” from Leinster seem certain to enjoy.
Nigel Owens - the logical choice for Pro12 final referee
As expected, the great Nigel Owens, the best referee in the world today, will have the whistle, with his fellow Welshmen, Ian Davies and Ben Whitehouse on flag duty, and another of the Rugby Taffia – Jon Mason, on TMO duties – a clear case of: “Who's the Mason in the truck”?
As yet the minor officials: fourth official, citing commissioner etc, have not been names, so, there might well be some Scottish input in those positions.



FORMER Scotland coach Andy Robinson is back in the big time, after his Bristol side beat Doncaster Knights in the English Championship play-off, to end their seven-year exile from England's top flight. Former Edinburgh and Scotland prop Kyle Traynor, (above), played his part in getting the West-Country club back to the big time.
 
Doncaster Knights, their opponents in the play-off, had a Scottish connection too. In their squad were Andy Bulumakau, elder brother of Glasgow and Scotland Sevens winger Junior, and Dougi Flockhart, who doubles-u as the Knights' Strength and Conditioning Coach.

Tuesday, 24 May 2016

Scotland Win At Twickenham - Sensation



The victorious Scotland Seven at Twickenham
JINGS, crivvens, michty me, whau'd hae thocht it – Scotland has won a tournament in the HSBC World Rugby Sevens Series. And what a place to break our duck at the top end of the tournament series – by winning the final event of the 2015-16 season, in London. I mean, Scotland does not win Sevens tournaments, and they most-certainly does not win at Twickenham. Is this perchance a sign?
So well done to all the Scottish squad. I think this single win, coming on the back as it did, of several bowl and plate wins across the series, has, hopefully, silenced for now, those who were calling for the SRU to ditch the Sevens squad.
Dougie Fife - ha a big weekend in London
A particular well done to Dougie Fife, who put a miserable domestic season with Edinburgh behind him with his performance is London. Also, we saw a rare piece of out of the box thinking by the Scots, when they produced a driving maul, from which they scored, in their final win over South Africa. Giving Scotland's traumatic relationship with driving mauls in 15-a-side rugby, to tear up the script and use one in Sevens, wow!!
I was speaking earlier this week to one poor guy who missed-out on Twickenham, Sevens squad regular Gavin Lowe, who is recovering from six weeks out with ankle ligament damage, sustained in the Hong Kong Sevens. But, Gavin was delighted for his mates, who have finally got the monkey off their backs. He is also raring to go with the extended Team GB Sevens squad, which he joins, in London next week, as they begin their preparations for the Olympic Games in Rio, in August.
Scotland is definitely under-represented with Team GB, maybe, if injuries become a factor, one or two more of the Twickenham heroes might make a late push to become Olympians.

I AM a wee bit concerned about Finn Russell. He has been transferred from the local hospital in Galway to a specialist hospital in Dublin, as he continues to recover from the very-severe head injury he sustained so early in Saturday night's game with Connacht.
Finn Russell - the lack of detail in the medical bulletins is worrying

Finn has already been withdrawn from the Scotland tour to Japan this summer, and while the official Glasgow Warriors press release concerning his injury is upbeat – there is a lack of detail which worries me.

A WEE word to Matt Horler and the hard-working guys and gals in the SRU's Media Department at BT Murrayfield. In the absence of an overview of club rugby by those Scottish newspapers which are traditionally supposed to bother about rugby – why not produce an end of season “report card” of who won what in the season which is ending.
Something like this:
BT Premiership winners: Ayr; Relegated: Selkirk
BT Premiership Play-Off winners: Heriot's; Runners-up: Ayr
National League 1 Champions: Watsonians; Relegated: Peebles, Kelso
National League 2 Champions: Hamilton; Runners-up and also promoted: Falkirk; Relegated Lasswade and Greenock Wanderers
National League 3 Champions: Glasgow High-Kelvinside; Runners-up and also promoted: West of Scotland; Relegated: East Kilbride, Irvine and Berwick.
Caledonian League Division One Champions (promoted to NL3): Highland; Relegated Mackie Academy FP and Hillfoots.
Caledonian League Division Two Midlands Champions (promoted to CL1) Alloa; Relegated: Blairgowrie.
Caledonian League Division Two North Champions (promoted to CL1): Deeside; Relegated: Lochaber.
Caledonian League Division Three Midlands Champions: Crieff and Strathearn; Relegated: Bo'ness.
Caledonian League Division Three North Champions: Highland 2nd XV.
Caledonian League Division Four Midlands Champions: Stirling County 3rd XV.
East Regional League Division One Champions: (promoted to NL3): St Boswell's; Relegated: Hawick Linden
East Regional League Division Two Champions: Penicuik; Relegated: Langholm
East Regional League Division Three: Champions: Earlston.
West Division One: Champions (promoted to NL3): Glasgow Academicals; Relegated: Cambuslang, Lenzie
West Division Two: Champions: Annan; Relegated: Strathendrick, Isle of Arran
West Division Three: Champions: Millbrae; also promoted: Strathaven; Relegated: Clydesdale and Lanark
West Division Four : Champions: Police Scotland (Glasgow); also promoted: Isle of Mull.
That is how it should look, re-organisation and other unforseen events might change things, however.

Sunday, 22 May 2016

Galway Gloom A Sad End To Glasgow's Season

IT WAS very disappointing, downright heart-breaking, but, Glasgow were unable to extend their defence of the guinness Pro12 title all the way to the Grand Final, after Saturday night's defeat by Connacht, in Galway.
Let me straight, from the outset – the better team won, and deservedly so. Connacht have been the most-consistent side in the Pro12 all season, they deserve their place in the final, at Murrayfield, on Saturday. That final will be an all-Irish affair, the country cousins from the far West of Ireland, against the city slicker “Dubs” from Leinster. I will, of course, be backing Connacht – well, you would always rather your side lost to the eventual champions.
But, being Scottish, I have to be disappointed that Glasgow lost. The truth is, the Glasgow magic seemed to evaporate during that loss to Connacht in the final regular season game, in Galway, a couple of weeks ago. We hoped they could recover from that, but, they couldn't. Ok, the loss of Finn Russell, and to a certain extent Simone Favaro, greatly handicapped Glasgow, but, the spark just wasn't there. On which subject, I trust Finn is not so-badly hurt as first reports appear to indicate.

Finn Russell - his injury looks serious
After Hibs' brilliant Scottish Cup win on Saturday, and mindful of the Irish invasion which will hit Edinburgh on Saturday – the capital will definitely be the place to be on Saturday night – the craic will be good, very good indeed.
Yesterday's game was a disappointing way for Leone Nakarawa's time at Scotstoun to end, we will miss the big man greatly, but, I have confidence in Toony being able to find someone with the X-factor of Leone and Miko - “the Weegies frae Fiji” for next season.
 D'arcy Rae - came of age in Galway

I was personally very happy for the little-known and under-rated D'arcy Rae, who came off the bench to replace Zandr Fagerson and never took a backward step. The big boy from Troon, more-often seen in an Ayr shirt,  put in a shift and a half.

EARLIER, I watched Saracens put Leicester to the sword in the English play-off semi-final. This was, in many ways a typical English game, with Saracens' all-round professionalism and excellence carrying the day. I thought Duncan Taylor again showed what a terrific player he is. I hope the injury he sustained is not so-serious that it keeps him out of the tour to Japan.
And, well done too to Exeter, who will meet Sarries at Twickenham on Saturday. Their rise to the top has been brilliant, in Rob Baxter they have a wonderful Director of Rugby and I am sure, Saturday's final will be a cracker.

I ALMOST forgot – well done big “Morry”, The Scotsman Group's Iain Morrison, who, on Thursday night, was inducted into the London Scottish Hall of Fame. 
Iain Morrison playing for Scotland 

Saturday, 21 May 2016

The Action Will Be Blazing In Galway Tonight

AS I type this, the sun is fighting a losing battle to emerge from a slate-grey sky, but, it is dry. Let us hope it remains dry out there at Galway, in the West of Ireland for tonight's Guinness Pro12 play-off semi-final between Connacht and Glasgow.
As we all know, the statistics do not stack up in Glasgow's favour, a home semi-final has, hitherto pretty much proved to be a free pass into the Pro12 Final. But, if any team can buck these odds, it is the Warriors. On paper, they are the better team, playing the more-attractive style of rugby. I do not think Connacht, great season though they have had, can play any better than they did in the meeting of the two clubs in the final regular season match, a couple of weeks ago – Glasgow can play a lot better than they did that night, and, if they do, they will win.
Gregor Townsend - will be hopng his real Glasgow shows up tonight 
One difference between the two games is, tonight the complete officiating tea will be neutral. Marius Mitrea of Italy is the man in the middle, which, I must admit, worries me somewhat. However, the great Nigel Owens is on one flag and I am sure he will keep the Connacht defensive line a lot more honest than the Irish touch judges allowed them to be two weeks ago.
Hopefully touch judge Nigel Owens can keep the Connacht defence honest tonight
It will still be a terrific game, as will the other semi-final, a traditional North v South encounter between Ulster and Leinster at the latter's Royal Dublin Showground base. Everything points to this one being settled with less than a score between the sides.
The line-ups for tonight's Galway game are:


EARLIER today, we have the two Aviva Premiership play-off semi-finals, between Saracens and Leicester and Exeter and Wasps. There is Scottish interest in both games, and, while quite frankly it does not bother me at all which side emerges on top from the Exeter v Wasps game – these are two of my favourite English sides, both of whom play a very attractive style of rugby; not merely because my late elder brother played for Sarries, but also because they play the better rugby and have the greater Scottish presence, I am putting my fez on Sarries to keep their dream of an English Championship-European Cup double alive.

Also, I just don't like Leicester, never have. Mind you, their need for victory is probably greater. They have, for a long time, had the sporting bragging rights in Leicester, then, along came Claudio Ranieri and his Foxes to shunt them aside.